Effect of spectral response curves on accuracy of combustion measurement techniques based on two-color method
HAN Lei;CHENG Yong;ZHU Ningjing;WANG Zhe;HUANG Zhifeng;
Abstract:
The two-color method based on CCD cameras is widely used for measuring the combustion temperature field and soot volume fraction field, playing an important role in understanding combustion laws and mastering combustion states. However, most of the existing work ignores the spectral response characteristics of CCD cameras and regards the detection signals of each channel of the CCD camera as the radiant energy of the flame at a specific wavelength, which brings errors to the measurement results of combustion temperature and soot volume fraction. In this work, an ethylene/air laminar diffusion flame was considered. The impact of various parameters of the spectral response curves(SRC), such as shape, half width, and asymmetry, on the accuracy of reconstructed flame temperature and soot concentration were analyzed. It is found that the influence of SRC shape and bandwidth on the reconstruction accuracy is small, the reconstruction errors of the temperature field are all below 1% without considering signal error. If the SRC is asymmetric or the center wavelength is inaccurate, there are relatively larger errors in the reconstruction results, and the errors of the temperature field may achieve 2.4% without considering signal error. Through experimental measurement of ethylene laminar diffusion flame by a CCD camera, it is found that there is a significant deviation between the measurement results using the center wavelength and the actual SRC, and the maximum temperature and maximum soot volume fraction errors are 4.74% and 16.4%, respectively.
Key Words: spectral response curve;CCD camera;combustion detection;two-color method;flame temperature field;soot volume fraction
Foundation: 国家自然科学基金资助项目(52076155)
Authors: HAN Lei;CHENG Yong;ZHU Ningjing;WANG Zhe;HUANG Zhifeng;
DOI: 10.13226/j.issn.1006-6772.LC24012601
References:
- [1] 孙晓刚,戴景民,丛大成,等.基于多光谱法的固体火箭发动机羽焰温度测量[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2003,43(7):916-918,922.SUN Xiaogang,DAI Jingmin,CONG Dacheng,et al.Plume temperature measurement of a solid propellant ro cket engine using multispectral thermometry[J].Journal of Tsinghua Univ-ersity (Science and Technology),2003,43(7):916-918,922.
- [2] 周怀春.炉内火焰可视化检测原理与技术[M].北京:科学出版社,2005.
- [3] LIU X J,LU H,YUAN B X,et al.A double-ended Raman temperature measurement method for hazardous chemicals warehouse[J].Optik,2018,169:62-68.
- [4] WEN D X,WANG Y.Spatially and temporally resolved temperature measurements in counterflow flames using a single interband cascade laser[J].Optics Express,2020,28(25):37879-37902.
- [5] 田子阳,赵会杰,尉昊赟,等.基于混合飞秒/皮秒相干反斯托克斯拉曼散射的动态高温燃烧场温度测量[J].物理学报,2021,70(21):131-139.TIAN Ziyang,ZHAO Huijie,WEI Haoyun,et al.Thermometry in dynamic and high-temperature combustion filed based on hybrid femtosecond/picosecond coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering[J].Acta Physica Sinica,2021,70(21):131-139.
- [6] HIGUCHI Y,NUNOME Y,TAKADA S,et al.Quantitative OH co-ncentration measurement using OH(2,0) band bi-directional LIF method for high-pressure and high-temperature symmetrical flames[J].Journal of Thermal Science and Technology,2022,17(3):22-00216.
- [7] LOU C,ZHOU H C,YU P F,et al.Measurements of the flame emissivity and radiative properties of particulate medium in pulverized-coal-fired boiler furnaces by image processing of visible radiation[J].Proceedings of the Combustion Institute,2007,31(2):2771-2778.
- [8] LOU C,ZHOU H C.Simultaneous determination of distributions of temperature and soot volume fraction in sooting flames using decoupled reconstruction method[J].Numerical Heat Transfer,Part A:Applications,2009,56(2):153-169.
- [9] 娄春,张鲁栋,蒲旸,等.基于自发辐射分析的被动式燃烧诊断技术研究进展[J].实验流体力学,2021,35(1):1-17.LOU Chun,ZHANG Ludong,PU Yang,et al.Research advances in passive techniques for combustion diagnostics based on analysis of spontaneous emission radiation[J].Journal of Experiments in Fluid Mechanics,2021,35(1):1-17.
- [10] 单良,杨鹏,洪波,等.单CCD相机的双光路温度测量方法[J].中国计量大学学报,2018,29(4):351-357.SHAN Liang,YANG Peng,HONG Bo,et al.A temperature measuring method with a dual optical paths structure based on CCD cameras[J].Journal of China University of Metrology,2018,29(4):351-357.
- [11] 何建东,汪亚明,郑俊褒.基于自由火焰图像的三维温度场重建方法研究[J].工业控制计算机,2013,26(3):75-77.HE Jiandong,WANG Yaming,ZHENG Junbao.Reconstruction of three-dimensional temperature distribution based on free flame images[J].Industrial Control Computer,2013,26(3):75-77.
- [12] NI M J,ZHANG H D,WANG F,et al.Study on the detection of three-dimensional soot temperature and volume fraction fields of a laminar flame by multispectral imaging system[J].Applied Thermal Engineering,2016,96:421-431.
- [13] WANG F,XIE Z C,YAN J H,et al.Simultaneous measurement of three-dimensional particle temperature,particle concentrati-on,and H2O concentration distributions using multispectral flame images[J].Combustion Science and Technology,2017,189(11):1891-1906.
- [14] 张昆,常丹华,陈瑞强,等.CCD辐射测温的数值解析及误差校正[J].传感技术学报,2010,23(2):225-228.ZHANG Kun,CHANG Danhua,CHEN Ruiqiang,et al.Numerical analysis and error correction of CCD radiation thermometry[J].Chinese Journal of Sensors and Actuators,2010,23(2):225-228.
- [15] ZHOU Z,TIAN D L,WU Z H,et al.3-D reconstruction of flame temperature distribution using tomographic and two-color pyrometric techniques[J].IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement,2015,64(11):3075-3084.
- [16] HAO C,LIU Z W,XIE H M,et al.Real-time measurement method of melt pool temperature in the directed energy deposition process[J].Applied Thermal Engineering,2020,177:115475.
- [17] 周颖慧.基于CCD图像传感原理的温度监测方法及应用研究[D].秦皇岛:燕山大学,2010.
- [18] YAN W J,LOU C.Two-dimensional distributions of temperature and soot volume fraction inversed from visible flame images[J].Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science,2013,50:229-233.
- [19] YAN W J,HU Z C,LI K Y,et al.Numerical simultaneous determination of non-uniform soot temperature and volume fraction from visible flame images[J].Energies,2022,15(8):2770.
- [20] LIU F S,THOMSON K A,SMALLWOOD G J.Soot temperature and volume fraction retrieval from spectrally resolved flame emission measurement in laminar axisymmetric coflow diffusion flames:Effect of self-absorption[J].Combustion and Flame,2013,160(9):1693-1705.
- [21] MODEST M F.Radiative properties of particulate media[M]//Radiative heat transfer.Amsterdam:Elsevier,2013:387-439.
- [22] CHANG H,CHARALAMPOPOULOS T.Determination of the wavele-ngth dependence of refractive indices of flame soot[J].Proceedings of the Royal Society of London.Series A:Mathematical and Physical Sciences,1990,430:577-591.
- [23] 谢正超,王飞,严建华,等.炉膛三维温度场重建中Tikhonov正则化和截断奇异值分解算法比较[J].物理学报,2015,64(24):21-28.XIE Zhengchao,WANG Fei,YAN Jianhua,et al.Comparative studies of Tikhonov regularization and truncated singular value decomposition in the three-dimensional flame temperature field reconstruction[J].Acta Physica Sinica,2015,64(24):21-28.
- [24] TIKHONOV A N.Inverse problems in heat conduction[J].Jour-nal of Engineering Physics,1975,29(1):816-820.
- [25] AKESSON E O,DAUN K J.Parameter selection methods for axisymmetric flame tomography through Tikhonov regularization[J].Applied Optics,2008,47(3):407-416.
- [26] SNELLING D R,THOMSON K A,SMALLWOOD G J,et al.Sp-ectrally resolved measurement of flame radiation to determine soot temperature and concentration[J].AIAA Journal,2002,40:1789-1795.
- spectral response curve
- CCD camera
- combustion detection
- two-color method
- flame temperature field
- soot volume fraction
- HAN Lei
- CHENG Yong
- ZHU Ningjing
- WANG Zhe
- HUANG Zhifeng
- School of Power and Mechanical Engineering
- Wuhan University
- HAN Lei
- CHENG Yong
- ZHU Ningjing
- WANG Zhe
- HUANG Zhifeng
- School of Power and Mechanical Engineering
- Wuhan University