孙旭东,成雪蕾,王树萌,王佳伟,赵玉莹,张博
SUN Xudong,CHENG Xuelei,WANG Shumeng,WANG Jiawei,ZHAO Yuying,ZHANG Bo

• 1:中国矿业大学(北京)管理学院
• 2:北京亿华通科技股份有限公司
• 3:厦门大学管理学院

摘要(Abstract)：

新能源发电制氢技术不断成熟，制氢成本直接影响氢能产业商业化推广与应用。针对电解水制氢技术方案投入与运营成本变化，基于新能源产业风光发电成本视角构建了碱性(ALK)电解槽+风电、质子交换膜(PEM)电解槽+风电、碱性(ALK)电解槽+光伏发电、质子交换膜(PEM)电解槽+光伏发电4种电解水制氢组合方案的成本动态测算模型，并通过敏感性分析研究了相关因素对制氢成本的影响。结果表明：4组方案制氢成本在研究期内(2017—2020年)分别降低了13.95%、29.22%、19.55%和31.03%,2020年制氢成本分别为17.90、28.27、21.54和32.23元/kg,而能耗和发电成本是降低4种方案制氢成本最具潜力的影响因素。同时，对比分析了其他电源及传统化石能源制氢等不同制氢技术工艺的经济性，不同制氢情景下，制氢成本由低到高分别为煤制氢、工业副产氢、天然气制氢、煤制氢+碳捕获收集(CCS)、ALK风电制氢、甲醇制氢、ALK光伏制氢、ALK谷电制氢、PEM光伏制氢和PEM谷电制氢。
With the gradual maturity of hydrogen production from new energy generation, the cost of hydrogen production directly affects the commercialization and application of hydrogen energy industry. Based on the changes of input and operating cost of water electrolysis hydrogen production technology, a dynamic cost calculation model was constructed for four combined schemes of electrolytic water hydrogen production, including alkaline water electrolysis cell(ALK) + wind power, proton exchange membrane water electrolysis cell(PEM) + wind power, alkaline water electrolysis cell(ALK) + photovoltaic(PV) power and proton exchange membrane water electrolysis cell(PEM) + photovoltaic(PV) power, from the respective of new energy generation cost. And the impact of relevant factors on the cost of hydrogen production was studied through sensitivity analysis. The results show that the cost of hydrogen production of four combination schemes reduces by 13.95%, 29.22%, 19.55% and 31.03%, respectively, during the research period(2017—2020), and the cost of hydrogen production in 2020 is 17.90, 28.27, 21.54 and 32.23 yuan/kg, respectively. Power consumption and power generation cost are the most potential factors to reduce the cost of hydrogen production in the four schemes. Through the comparative analysis of the economy of different hydrogen production technologies such as other power sources and traditional petrochemical energy, it is found that in different hydrogen production scenarios, the hydrogen production technologies from low to high cost are hydrogen production from coal, industrial by-product, natural gas, coal + Carbon Capture and Storage(CCS), ALK wind power, methanol, ALK PV, ALK valley electricity, PEM PV and PEM valley electricity.

关键词(KeyWords)： 风力发电;光伏发电;成本估算;电解水制氢;敏感性分析
wind power generation;photovoltaic power generation;cost estimation;electrolysis of water to produce hydrogen;sensitivity analysis

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 中国工程院资助项目(2023-PP-06-03);; 国家重点研发计划资助项目(2017YFB0601905-2);; 国家自然科学基金资助项目(72088101)

作者(Author): 孙旭东,成雪蕾,王树萌,王佳伟,赵玉莹,张博
SUN Xudong,CHENG Xuelei,WANG Shumeng,WANG Jiawei,ZHAO Yuying,ZHANG Bo

DOI: 10.13226/j.issn.1006-6772.CN22071501

参考文献(References)：

• [1] 郑津洋.高安全下低成本大容量高压储氢[J].浙江大学学报(工学版),2020,54(9):1655-1657.ZHENG Jinyang.High safety,low cost,large capacity storage of high pressure gaseous hydrogen[J].Journal of Zhejiang University (Engineering Science) ,2020,54(9):1655-1657.
• [2] 邵志刚，衣宝廉.氢能与燃料电池发展现状及展望[J].中国科学院院刊，2019,34(4):469-477.SHAO Zhigang,YI Baolian.Developing trend and present status of hydrogen energy and fuel cell development[J].Bulletin of the Chinese Academy of Sciences,2019,34(4):469-477.
• [3] 杨浩.氢在能源转型变革中的潜在优势分析[J].分布式能源，2020,5(3):47-54.YANG Hao.Potential advantages of hydrogen in transformation of energy resources[J].Distributed Energy,2020,5(3):47-54.
• [4] 许世森，张瑞云，程健，等.电解制氢与高温燃料电池在电力行业的应用与发展[J].中国电机工程学报，2019,39(9):2531-2537.XU Shisen,ZHANG Ruiyun,CHENG Jian,et al.Application and development of electrolytic hydrogen production and high temperature fuel cell in electric power industry[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2019,39(9):2531-2537.
• [5] 甘霖，朱云翔.大型水电企业电解水制氢经济可行性分析[J].科技资讯，2019,17(32):22-24.GAN Lin,ZHU Yunxiang.Economic feasibility analysis of hydrogen production from electrolysis water in large hydropower enterprises[J].Science & Technology Information,2019,17(32):22-24.
• [6] IRENA.Green hydrogen:A guide to policy making[R].Abu Dhabi:International Renewable Energy Agency,2020.
• [7] 中国氢能联盟，国际氢能委员会.氢能平价之路[R].北京：中国氢能联盟，2020.
• [8] 郭秀盈，李先明，许壮，等.可再生能源电解制氢成本分析[J].储能科学与技术，2020,9(3):688-695.GUO Xiuying,LI Xianming,XU Zhuang,et al.Cost analysis of hydrogen production by electrolysis of renewable energy[J].Energy Storage Science and Technology,2020,9(3):688-695.
• [9] 郭博文，罗聃，周红军.可再生能源电解制氢技术及催化剂的研究进展[J].化工进展，2021,40(6):2933-2951.GUO Bowen,LUO Dan,ZHOU Hongjun.Recent advances in renewable energy electrolysis hydrogen production technology and related electrocatalysts[J].Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress,2021,40(6):2933-2951.
• [10] CHI J,YU H M.Water electrolysis based on renewable energy for hydrogen production[J].Chinese Journal of Catalysis,2018,39(3):390-394.
• [11] 田甜，李怡雪，黄磊，等.海上风电制氢技术经济性对比分析[J].电力建设，2021,42(12):136-144.TIAN Tian,LI Yixue,HUANG Lei,et al.Comparative analysis on the economy of hydrogen production technology for offshore wind power consumption[J].Electric Power Construction,2021,42(12):136-144.
• [12] 张理，叶斌，尹晨旭，等.风电制氢经济性及发展前景分析[J].东北电力技术，2020,41(7):5-9,37.ZHANG Li,YE Bin,YIN Chenxu,et al.Economy and development prospects analysis of wind power hydrogen production[J].Northeast Electric Power Technology,2020,41(7):5-9,37.
• [13] 刘庆超，杨畅，周正华.光伏发电制氢技术经济可行性研究[J].电力设备管理，2019,(11):92-93.LIU Qingchao,YANG Chang,ZHOU Zhenghua.Study on economic feasibility of photovoltaic hydrogen generation technology[J].Electric Power Equipment Management,2019(11):92-93.
• [14] AYODELE T R,MUNDA J L.Potential and economic viability of green hydrogen production by water electrolysis using wind energy resources in South Africa[J].International Journal of Hydrogen Energy,2019,44(33):17669-17687.
• [15] 王彦哲，周胜，周湘文，等.中国不同制氢方式的成本分析[J].中国能源，2021,43(5):29-37.WANG Yanzhe,ZHOU Sheng,ZHOU Xiangwen,et al.Cost analysis of different hydrogen production methods in China[J].Energy of China,2021,43(5):29-37.
• [16] PROOST J.Critical assessment of the production scale required for fossil parity of green electrolytic hydrogen[J].International Journal of Hydrogen Energy,2020,45(35):17067-17075.
• [17] MILANI D,KIANI A,MCNAUGHTON R.Renewable-powered hydrogen economy from Australia′s perspective[J].International Journal of Hydrogen Energy,2020,45(46):24125-24145.
• [18] IREN.Hydrogen from renewable power:Technology outlook for the energy transition[R].Abu Dhabi:International Renewable Energy Agency,2018.
• [19] 中国氢能联盟.中国氢能源及燃料电池产业白皮书(2020)[M].北京：人民日报出版社，2021.
• [20] Hydrogen Council,McKinsey & Company.Hydrogen Insights 2021:A perspective on hydrogen investment,deployment and cost competitiveness[R].Belgium:Hydrogen Council,2021.
• [21] PAVAN A M,LUGHI V,ROSATO P,et al.Diminishing cost of electricity from wind power and photovoltaics[C]//2017 IEEE International Conference on Environment and Electrical Engineering and 2017 IEEE Industrial and Commercial Power Systems Europe (EEEIC /I&CPS Europe).Milan(IT):IEEE,2017:1-4.
• [22] LAGAROS N D,KARLAFTIS M G,PAIDA M K.Stochastic life-cycle cost analysis of wind parks[J].Reliability Engineering & System Safety,2015,144:117-127.
• [23] 王思聪.中国海陆风电成本研究[J].宏观经济研究，2019(8):170-175.WANG Sicong.A study on onshore and offshore wind power cost in China[J].Scientific Management Research,2019(8):170-175.
• [24] 潘彬彬，陈祉好，贾楠菲，等.关于光伏发电成本核算问题的研究：基于LCOE方法的分析[J].价格理论与实践，2019(5):138-140,144.PAN Binbin,CHEN Zhihao,JIA Nanfei,et al.Research on cost accounting of photovoltaic power generation:Analysis based on LCOE method[J].Price:Theory & Practice,2019(5):138-140,144.
• [25] TU Q,BETZ R,MO J L,et al.The profitability of onshore wind and solar PV power projects in China:A comparative study[J].Energy Policy,2019,132:404-417.
• [26] 鲁正，陈芸菲，孙炜.基于优化LCOE的光伏平价上网可行性分析[J].太阳能学报，2021,42(8):153-158.LU Zheng,CHEN Yunfei,SUN Wei.Feasibility analysis of photovoltaic power to grid parity based on optimized lcoe model[J].Acta Energiae Solaris Sinica,2021,42(8):153-158.
• [27] TU Q,BETZ R,MO J L,et al.Achieving grid parity of wind power in China:Present levelized cost of electricity and future evolution[J].Applied Energy,2019,250:1053-1064.
• [28] CHEN H,GAO X Y,LIU J Y,et al.The grid parity analysis of onshore wind power in China:A system cost perspective[J].Renewable Energy,2020,148:22-30.
• [29] 张运洲，刘俊，张晋芳，等.中国新能源“后补贴时期”发展分析[J].中国电力，2019,52(4):1-7.ZHANG Yunzhou,LIU Jun,ZHANG Jinfang,et al.Study on the development of renewable energy during "Post-Subsidy Period" in China[J].Electric Power,2019,52(4):1-7.
• [30] 李志学，秦子蕊，王换换，等.我国风电成本水平及其影响因素研究[J].价格理论与实践，2019(10):24-29,166.LI Zhixue,QIN Zirui,WANG Huanhuan,et al.Study on wind power cost level and its influencing factors in China[J].Price:Theory & Practice,2019(10):24-29,166.
• [31] 王周.天然气制氢、甲醇制氢与水电解制氢的经济性对比探讨[J].天然气技术与经济，2016,10(6):47-49,83.WANG Zhou.Economical comparison of hydrogen production from natural gas,methanol and hydroelectricity[J].Natural Gas Technology,2016,10(6):47-49,83.
• [32] 刘秀堂.200张图表学精益管理：IE工厂效率提升方法[M].北京：中华工商联合出版社，2020.
• [33] 张轩，王凯，樊昕晔，等.电解水制氢成本分析[J].现代化工，2021,41(12):7-11.ZHANG Xuan,WANG Kai,FAN Xinhua,et al.Cost analysis on hydrogen production via water electrolysis[J].Modern Chemical Industry,2021,41(12):7-11.
• [34] 中国汽车工程学会.世界氢能与燃料电池汽车产业发展报告(2019)[M].北京：机械工业出版社，2020.
• [35] 中国氢能联盟.中国氢能源及燃料电池产业白皮书(2019)[R].潍坊：中国氢能联盟，2019.
• [36] 中国汽车技术研究中心有限公司，荷兰皇家壳牌集团.中国车用氢能产业发展报告(2019)[M].北京：社会科学文献出版社，2019.
• [37] 中国标准化研究院，全国氢能标准化技术委员会.中国氢能产业基础设施发展蓝皮书(2018):低碳低成本氢源的实现路径[M].北京：中国标准出版社，2018.
• [38] 符冠云，郁聪，白泉.“氢能热”下的“冷思考”:谨防化石能源制氢形成的高碳锁定效应[J].中国经贸导刊，2019(12):44-47.FU Guanyun,YU Cong,BAI Quan."Cold thinking" under "hydrogen heat":Beware of the high carbon lock-in effect of hydrogen production from fossil fuels[J].China Economic & Trade Herald,2019(12):44-47.
• [39] 程婉静，李俊杰，刘欢，等.两种技术路线的煤制氢产业链生命周期成本分析[J].煤炭经济研究，2020,40(3):4-11.CHENG Wanjing,LI Junjie,LIU Huan,et al.Analysis of life cycle cost of coal hydrogen production chain based on two technical routes[J].Coal Economic Research,2020,40(3):4-11.
• [40] 张轩，樊昕晔，吴振宇，等.氢能供应链成本分析及建议[J].化工进展，2022,41(5):2364-2371.ZHANG Xuan,FAN Xinye,WU Zhenyu,et al.Hydrogen energy supply chain cost analysis and suggestions[J].Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress,2022,41(5):2364-2371.
• [41] 单彤文，宋鹏飞，李又武，等.制氢、储运和加注全产业链氢气成本分析[J].天然气化工(C1化学与化工),2020,45(1):85-90,96.SHAN Tongwen,SONG Pengfei,LI Youwu,et al.Cost analysis of hydrogen from the perspective of the whole industrial chain of production,storage,transportation and refueling[J].Natural Gas Chemical Industry (C1 Chemistry and Chemical Engineering),2020,45(1):85-90,96.
• [42] 蒋珊.绿氢制取成本预测及与灰氢、蓝氢对比[J].石油石化绿色低碳，2022,7(2):6-11.JIANG Shan.Cost prediction:Green hydrogen vs grey/blue hydrogen[J].Green Petroleum & Petrochemicals,2022,7(2):6-11.
• [43] 刘玮，万燕鸣，熊亚林，等.碳中和目标下电解水制氢关键技术及价格平准化分析[J].电工技术学报，2022,37(11):2888-2896.LIU Wei,WANG Yanming,XIONG Yalin.Key technology of water electrolysis and levelized cost of hydrogen analysis under carbon neutral vision[J].Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society,2022,37(11):2888-2896.
• [44] 滕欣余，张国华，胡辰树，等.我国典型城市氢能经济性和低成本氢源探索分析[J].化工进展，2022,41(12):6295-6301.TENG Xinyu,ZHANG Guohua,HU Chenshu,et al.Analysis on hydrogen energy economy and low cost of hydrogen source in typical cities of China[J].Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress,2022,41(12):6295-6301.
• [45] 王彦哲，欧训民，周胜.基于学习曲线的中国未来制氢成本趋势研究[J].气候变化研究进展，2022,18(3):283-293.WANG Yanzhe,OU Xunmin,ZHOU Sheng.Future cost trend of hydrogen production in China based on learning curve[J].Climate Change Research,2022,18 (3):283-293.
• [46] 徐进，丁显，宫永立，等.电解水制氢厂站经济性分析[J].储能科学与技术，2022,11(7):2374-2385.XU Jin,DING Xian,GONG Yongli,et al.Economic analysis of hydrogen production plant with water electrolysis[J].Energy Storage Science and Technology,2022,11 (7):2374-2385.