陈翰,姚禹歌,张国庆,张代鑫,马有福,黄中
CHEN Han,YAO Yuge,ZHANG Guoqing,ZHANG Daixin,MA Youfu,HUANG Zhong

• 1:清华大学能源与动力工程系
• 2:上海理工大学能源与动力工程学院
• 3:中国矿业大学(北京)化学与环境工程学院
• 4:太原理工大学电气与动力工程学院

摘要(Abstract)：

炉内受热面磨损是影响循环流化床锅炉长周期安全稳定的主要因素，锅炉设计结构、燃用煤质特性、运行控制方式、检修维护水平等因素均会对磨损造成影响。磨损多集中于颗粒浓度高、烟气流速大、流场发生突变的区域，如炉膛密相区、过渡区、屏式受热面连接区、稀相区不规则部位、炉顶部和炉膛出口等位置。为减轻炉内磨损带来的危害，循环流化床锅炉一般通过降低炉膛烟气流速、让管设计、采用主动防磨或被动防磨技术手段进行防护。从使用效果来看，防磨梁、防磨格栅、金属喷涂、激光熔敷(熔覆)等措施均能在一定程度上缓解炉内受热面磨损，防磨技术的选用需要综合考虑其对炉内传热的影响以及检修维护的便利性，总体而言应用较广泛且效果较好的是金属格栅与金属喷涂或激光熔敷(熔覆)相结合的组合防磨技术。目前，循环流化床锅炉炉内磨损问题已得到有效控制，锅炉的连续运行周期和安全性显著改善。
The wear of the heating surfaces is a key parameter on the long-term safe and stable operation for a circulating fluidized bed(CFB) boiler, and the wear is affected by many factors, such as the structure of the furnace, coal characteristics, operation method, and maintenance. Abrasion is always concentrated on areas with high solid volume fraction, high flow rate of flue gas and abrupt changes in flow field, such as dense zone, transition zone, connection area of platen heating surface, irregular parts in dilute region, the roof and outlet of furnace, and so on. Therefore, lower velocity of flue gas, the design of kick-out tube, and positive or passive anti-wearing methods are widely adopted to protect heating surfaces for purpose of attenuating adverse effects of the wear on the operation. As for the anti-wear effectiveness, anti-wear beam, metal grid, metal spraying, and laser cladding can all reduce the wear in the furnace to a certain extent, the influence on heat transfer and the convenience of inspection and maintenance need to be taken into consideration before selection of anti-wear technology.In general, the combination of metal grid and metal spraying or laser cladding has achieved the best use effect. At present, the wear problem in the furnace of the CFB boiler has been under effective control. The CFB boilers can continuously operate for longer hours and the operation safety has been significantly improved.

关键词(KeyWords)： 循环流化床锅炉;受热面磨损;磨损影响因素;防磨梁;防磨格栅;激光熔敷(熔覆)
CFB boiler;wear on heating surfaces;factors of wear;anti-wear beam;anti-wear grid;laser cladding

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家能源投资集团科技创新资助项目(神华准能2021-1729);; 国网冀北电力公司科技资助项目(SGTYHT/21-HS-225)

作者(Author): 陈翰,姚禹歌,张国庆,张代鑫,马有福,黄中
CHEN Han,YAO Yuge,ZHANG Guoqing,ZHANG Daixin,MA Youfu,HUANG Zhong

DOI: 10.13226/j.issn.1006-6772.22012503

参考文献(References)：

• [1] 黄中，杨娟，车得福.大容量循环流化床锅炉技术发展应用现状[J].热力发电，2019,48(6):1-8.HUANG Zhong,YANG Juan,CHE Defu.Application and development status of large-scale CFB boilers[J].Thermal Power Generation,2019,48(6):1-8.
• [2] 李建锋，周宏.中国300 MW等级循环流化床锅炉机组与煤粉锅炉机组可靠性对比与分析[J].中国电力，2016,49(1):14-18,22.LI Jianfeng,ZHOU Hong.Analysis and comparison on reliabilities of 300 MW circulating fluidized bed boiler units and pulverized coal boiler Units[J].Electric Power,2016,49(1):14-18,22.
• [3] 黄中，潘贵涛，张品高，等.300 MW大型循环流化床锅炉运行分析与发展建议[J].锅炉技术，2014,45(6):35-41.HUANG Zhong,PAN Guitao,ZHANG Pingao,et al.Operating condition and development proposal of 300 MW large-scale circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Boiler Technology,2014,45(6):35-41.
• [4] 孙献斌.CFB锅炉热效率与环保特性及可靠性分析[J].中国电力，2008,41(10):44-48.SUN Xianbin.Thermal efficiency and environment protective characteristics and reliability of CFB boilers[J].Electric Power,2008,41(10):44-48.
• [5] 岑可法，倪明江，骆仲泱，等.循环流化床锅炉理论设计与运行[M].北京：中国电力出版社，1998.
• [6] 黄中.循环流化床锅炉优化改造技术[M].北京：中国电力出版社，2019.
• [7] 冯俊凯，岳光溪，吕俊复.循环流化床燃烧锅炉[M].北京：中国电力出版社，2003.
• [8] WERTHER J.Fluid mechanics of large scale CFB units[C]//Avidan AA,ed.Circulation fluidized bed technology IV.NewYork:AIChE,1994:1-14.
• [9] NAKAMURA K,CAPES C E.Vertical pneumatic conveying:A theoretical study of uniform and annular particle flow models[J].The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering,1973,51:39-46.
• [10] CHENG Leming,ZHOU Xinglong,WANG Chao,et al.Gas-solids hydrodynamics in a CFB with 6 cyclones and a pant leg[C]//Proceedings of the Tenth International Conference on Circulating Fluidized Beds and Fluidization Technology.[S.l.]:Engineering Conferences International,2011:497-504.
• [11] 赵刚.循环流化床流动结构的可视化研究[D].上海：上海交通大学，2002.
• [12] XU J,ZHU J X.Experimental study on solids concentration distribution in a two-dimensional circulating fluidized bed[J].Chemical Engineering Science,2010,65(20):5447-5454.
• [13] 白丁荣，金涌，俞芷青.循环流态化(Ⅰ)[J].化学反应工程与工艺，1991(2):202-213.BAI Dingrong,JIN Yong,YU Zhiqing.Circulating fluidization(I)[J].Chemical Reaction Engineering and Technology,1991(2):202-213.
• [14] 周星龙.600 MW循环流化床锅炉炉膛气固流动和受热面传热的研究[D].杭州：浙江大学，2012.
• [15] ZHANG Nan,LU Bona,WANG Wei.3D CFD simulation of hydrodynamics of a 150 MWe circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2010,162(2):821-828.
• [16] HARTGE EU,BUDINGER S,WERTHER J,et al.Spatial effects in the combustion chamber of the 235 MWe CFB boiler turow No.3[C]//Circulating Fluidized Bed Technology VIII.Hangzhou:World Publishing Corporation,2005.
• [17] BASU P,FRASER S A.Circulating fluidized bed boilers:Design and operations[M].Boston:Butterworth-Heinemann,1991.
• [18] 张晓峰，方亮，邢建东，等.二体磨损与三体磨损之间的关系[J].西安公路交通大学学报，2000(3):93-97.ZHANG Xiaofeng,FANG Liang,XING Jiandong,et al.Relation between two-body abrasion and three-body abrasion[J].Journal of Xi′an Highway University,2000(3):93-97.
• [19] 方亮，杜道山，张晓峰，等.三体磨损中材料塑性变形磨损的数值模拟[J].西安交通大学学报，2003(3):268-272.FANG Liang,DU Daoshan,ZHANG Xiaofeng,et al.Numerical simulation of plastic deformation wear rate of materials under Three-body abrasion[J].Journal of Xi′an Jiao Tong University,2003(3):268-272.
• [20] 夏云飞.循环流化床锅炉水冷壁磨损机理与防止研究[D].杭州：浙江大学，2015.
• [21] ARNELL R D.Two-body abrasive wear of the surfaces of Pangol-in scales[J].Journal of Bionics Engineering,2007(2):77-84.
• [22] BITTER J G.A study of erosion phenomena[J].Wear,1963(6):5-21.
• [23] 方亮，杜道山，张晓峰，等.三体磨料磨损中塑变磨损的实验规律[C]//第七届全国摩擦学大会.北京：科学技术出版社，2002:233-237.
• [24] 薛希群.循环流化床锅炉磨损分析及对策[J].电力自动化设备，2003,23(1):82-84.XUE Xiqun.Analysis of abrasion and its countermeasur for circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Electric Power Automation Equipment,2003,23(1):82-84.
• [25] 沈志恒.循环流化床颗粒团聚作用的气固两相流动数值模拟[D].黑龙江：哈尔滨工业大学，2010.
• [26] 国家能源局.循环流化床锅炉防磨技术导则：DL/T 1906—2018[S].北京：中国电力出版社，2018.
• [27] 杨海瑞，肖显斌，吕俊复，等.CFB锅炉内成灰特性的实验研究方法[J].化工学报，2003(8):1183-1187.YANG Hairui,XIAO Xianbi,LYU Junfu,et al.Experimental technique on coal ash formation in CFB combustion[J].Journal of Chemica Industry and Engineering(China),2003(8):1183-1187.
• [28] 石奇光，马庆，徐开义，等.用飞灰物化特性预测灰磨损性能的试验研究[J].华东工业大学学报，1996(2):80-85.SHI Qiguang,MA Qing,XU Kaiyi,et al.Experimental study on predicting ash erosion performance based on the physical and chemical properties of fly ash[J].East China University of Technology,1996(2):80-85.
• [29] 孙亦騄.煤中矿物杂质对锅炉的危害[M].北京：水利电力出版社，1994.
• [30] 张妮乐，黄明达，高胜斌，等.根据煤灰成分判别CFB锅炉磨损特性的新方法[J].动力工程，2006,26(1):54-58.ZHANG Nile,HUANG Mingda,GAO Shengbin,et al.A new criterion for ascertaining the abrasion liability of CFB boilers by ash components[J].Journal of Power Engineering,2006,26(1):54-58.
• [31] 温智勇，谭晶，钟俊.煤质对电厂锅炉运行及经济性影响的研究[J].电力科学与工程，2012,28(9):72-78.WEN Zhiyong,TAN Jing,ZHONG Jun.Influence of different coals for power plant boiler operation and economy[J].Electric Power Science and Engineering,2012,28(9):72-78.
• [32] 双伟.川北低热值煤矸石循环流化床燃烧技术研究[D].重庆：重庆大学，2014.
• [33] 黄中，江建忠，徐正泉，等.循环流化床锅炉大比例煤泥掺烧试验研究[J].中国电机工程学报，2013,33(S1):112-116.HUANG Zhong,JIANG Jianzhong,XU Zhengquan,et al.Research on CFB boiler large proportion coal slime co-combustion test[J].Proceedings of the CSEE,2013,33(S1):112-116.
• [34] FINNIE I.Some observations on the erosion of ductile metals[J].Wear,1972,19(1):81-90.
• [35] MISRA A,FINNIE L,On the size effect in abrasive and erosion wear[J].Wear,1981(65):359-373.
• [36] 樊泉桂，崔震华，由俊坤，等.450 t/h循环流化床锅炉炉内受热面磨损探讨[J].电站系统工程，2007,23(2):37-38,40.FAN Quangui,CUI Zhenhua,YOU Junkun,et al.450 t/h circulation fluid bed heating surface attrition analysis[J].Power System Engineering,2007,23(2):37-38,40.
• [37] LINDSLEY B A,MARDER A R,LEWNARD J J.The effect of circulating fluidized bed particle characteristics on erosion of 1020 carbon steel[J].Wear,1995,188(1):33-39.
• [38] 马颖，任峻，李元东，等.冲蚀磨损研究的进展[J].兰州理工大学学报，2005,31(1):21-25.MA Ying,REN Jun,LI Yuandong,et al.Development of research on erosion of materials[J].Journal of Lanzhou University of Technology,2005,31(1):21-25.
• [39] BAHADUR S,BADURDDIN R.Erodent particle characterization and the effect of particle size and shape on erosion[J].Wear,1990,138(1/2):189-208.
• [40] SHIPWAY P H,HUTCHINGS I M,SCATTERGOOD R O.The role of particle properties in the erosion of brittle materials[J].Wear,1996,193:105-113.
• [41] 王家兴，高全，彭建升，等.循环流化床锅炉炉膛受热面磨损爆管分析与解决措施[J].工业锅炉，2021(5):55-60.WANG Jiaxing,GAO Quan,PENG Jiansheng,et al.Analysis and solution of abrasion and tube burst of furnace heating surface of circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Industrial Boilers,2021(5):55-60.
• [42] 王旭.300 MW循环流化床锅炉设备治理与运行优化[D].北京：华北电力大学，2012.
• [43] 康健悦.秦皇岛电厂300 MW循环流化床锅炉运行特性研究[D].北京：华北电力大学，2011.
• [44] 赖开忠，李越胜，李树学.440 t/h循环流化床锅炉水冷壁磨损原因分析和对策研究[J].电力设备，2008,9(7):52-54.LAI Kaizhong,LI Yuesheng,LI Shuxue.Cause analysis and countermeasures of water wall abrasion of 440 t/h CFB boilers[J].Electrical Equipment,2008,9(7):52-54.
• [45] 苗长信.循环流化床锅炉炉内受热面磨损分析及防范对策[J].中国电力，2005,38(11):35-39.MIAO Changxin.Abrasion analysis of heating surface in CFB boiler and its preventive measures[J].Electric Power,2005,38(11):35-39.
• [46] KIM Tae Woo,CHOI Jeong Hoo,SHUN Do W.Wear of water walls in a commercial circulating fluidized bed combustor with two gas exits[J].Powder Technology:An International Journal on the Science and Technology of Wet and Dry Particulate Systems,2007,178(3):143-150.
• [47] 侯祥松，张建胜，王进伟，等.循环流化床锅炉中水冷壁的磨损原理及其预防[J].锅炉技术，2007(4):19-24.HOU Xiangsong,ZHANG Jiansheng,WANG Jinwei,et al.The mechanism of the water wall erosion in a Circulating Fluidized Bed Boiler and its improvement[J].Boiler Technology,2007(4):19-24.
• [48] 周浩生，陆继东，刘德昌，等.循环流化床稀相区流动结构的实验研究[J].燃烧科学与技术，1998(4):61-65.ZHOU Haosheng,LU Jidong,LIU Dechang,et al.Flow structure in Circulating Fluidized Bed riser[J].Journal of Combustion Science and Technology,1998(4):61-65.
• [49] ZHOU J,LIM C J,BRERETON C M H,et al.Particle velocity profiles in a circulating fluidized bed riser of square cross-section[J].Chemical Engineering Science,1995,50(2):237-244.
• [50] VAN DE MEER E H,THORPE R B,DAVIDSON J F.Flow patterns in the square cross-section riser of a circulating fluidised bed and the effect of riser exit design[J].Chemical Engineering Science,2000,55(19):4079-4099.
• [51] 方占岭，牛树贇，代东，等.300 MW循环流化床锅炉水冷壁让管改造的成功应用[C]//全国电力行业CFB机组技术交流服务协作网第九届年会暨第二届中国循环流化床燃烧理论与技术学术会议论文集.贵阳：[s.n.],2010:538-542.
• [52] 步兆彬，徐秀国，石建国，等.HG-40/3.82-L.MG-18型CFB锅炉水冷壁防磨技术应用[C]//全国电力行业CFB机组技术交流服务协作网第十一届年会暨第三届中国循环流化机床燃烧理论与技术学术会议论文集.鄂尔多斯：[s.n.],2012:860-862.
• [53] 黄俊伟.150 t/h循环流化床锅炉炉膛磨损分析及防治措施[J].设备管理与维修，2012(1):50-53.HUANG Junwei.Analysis on wear and prevention measures in the furnace of a 150 t/h CFB boiler[J].Plant Maintenance Engineering,2012(1):50-53.
• [54] 黄中，江建忠，孙献斌.循环流化床锅炉磨损机理及对策[C]//循环流化床锅炉技术2010年会论文集.长沙：[s.n.],2010:125-128.
• [55] 石海峰.防磨导流梁在大型循环流化床锅炉上的应用[J].价值工程，2011,30(17):47-48.SHI Haifeng.Application of anti chafe diversion beam in large-scale circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Value Engineering,2011,30(17):47-48.
• [56] 周星龙，孙平，谢建文，等.大型循环流化床锅炉炉膛颗粒速度的光学测量[J].中国电力，2015,48(12):59-63.ZHOU Xinglong,SUN Ping,XIE Jianwen,et al.Optical measurement on particle velocity in a large-scale circulating fluidized bed boiler furnace[J].Electric Power,2015,48(12):59-63.
• [57] 王春娜，张林全，周雷.100 MW循环流化床锅炉长周期安全高效运行研究[J].应用能源技术，2014(2):20-23.WANG Chunna,ZHANG Linquan,ZHOU Lei.Study on long-term safe and efficient operation of a 100 MW CFB boiler[J].Applied Energy Technology,2014(2):20-23.
• [58] 任月平，高洪培，吕海生.CFB锅炉安装防磨梁效果及热流密度测试分析[J].洁净煤技术，2011,17(3):101-103.REN Yueping,GAO Hongpei,LYU Haisheng.Anti-wearing effect and heat flux density testing analysis of CFB boiler installing anti-wear device[J].Clean Coal Technology,2011,17(3):101-103.
• [59] 王则强.CFB锅炉非金属防磨梁实用技术探讨[J].电力技术，2010,19(6):30-32.WANG Zeqiang.Study of the operative technology of nonmetal wear strip fitting in CFB boiler[J].Electric Power Technology,2010,19(6):30-32.
• [60] 谭伟，孙广军，王晓东，等.循环流化床锅炉防磨梁设计加装不合理及处理措施[J].氮肥与合成气，2011,39(7):23-24.TAN Wei,SUN Guangjun,WANG Xiaodong,et al.Unreasonable design and installation of anti-wear beam and treatment measures of CFB boiler[J].Nitrogenous Fertilizer & Syngas,2011,39(7):23-24.
• [61] 崔永平，张志杰，苗冬立.220 t/h循环流化床锅炉加装防磨梁改造[C]//中国电机工程学会清洁高效发电技术协作网2014年会论文集.银川：[s.n.],2014:1-9.
• [62] 张全胜，许彪，李程.循环流化床锅炉垂直水冷壁耐磨3年以上的综合防磨技术[C]//全国电力行业CFB机组技术交流服务协作网技术交流会议.大连：[s.n.],2007:407-413.
• [63] 李建军.350 MW超临界循环流化床锅炉水冷壁磨损分析及策略[J].冶金与材料，2020,40(2):31-33.LI Jianjun.Analysis on wear of water wall and strategy of 350 MW supercritical circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Metallurgy and Materials,2020,40(2):31-33.
• [64] 侯万林.循环流化床锅炉防磨技术的探讨[J].能源科技，2021,19(3):64-67.HOU Wanlin.Discussion on anti-wear technology of circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Energy Science and Technology,2021,19(3):64-67.
• [65] 郭建利.300 MW CFB锅炉脱硝提效工艺研究与实施[C]//2016年中国电机工程学会年会论文集.南京：[s.n.],2016:1-3.
• [66] 郭旭超.浅谈300 MW循环流化床锅炉布风板阻力的重要性[J].科技风，2019(21):153.GUO Xuchao.Discussion on importance of 300 MW circulating fluidized bed boiler wind plate resistance[J].Technology Wind,2019(21):153.
• [67] 张代，史丽超.300 MW级循环流化床锅炉燃烧优化关键技术的实践研究[J].中国煤炭，2019,45(12):76-81.ZHANG Dai,SHI Lichao.Practical research on key technology of combustion optimization of 300 MW CFB boiler[J].China Coal,2019,45(12):76-81.
• [68] 胡传忻.热喷涂原理及应用[M].北京：中国科学技术出版社，1994.
• [69] 尹技虎，闫伟.超音速电弧喷涂技术在440 t/h CFB锅炉上的应用[J].表面技术，2004,33(6):77-79.YIN Jihu,YAN Wei.Application of supersonic arc spraying technology on a 440 t/h CFB boiler[J].Surface Technology,2004,33(6):77-79.
• [70] 刘海宝，周雷，王成.循环流化床锅炉激光熔覆水冷壁防磨技术浅析[J].电力系统装备，2019(10):118-120.LIU Haibao,ZHOU Lei,WANG Cheng.Analysis on laser cladding water wall anti-wear technology of circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Electric Power System Equipment,2019(10):118-120.
• [71] 胡金力，陈国星，黄科峰，等.垃圾焚烧循环流化床锅炉防磨热喷涂涂层失效机理及对策[J].热喷涂技术，2012,4(1):59-63.HU Jinli,CHEN Guoxing,HUANG Kefeng,et al.The failure mechanisms and solutions of anti-wear thermal spray coatings for solid waste incineration circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Thermal Spray Technology,2012,4(1):59-63.
• [72] 张林全.热电厂循环流化床锅炉长周期运行技术应用研究[J].中国设备工程，2020(2):142-144.ZHANG Linquan.Research on the application of long-cycle operation technology of circulating fluidized bed boiler in thermal power plant[J].China Plant Engineering,2020(2):142-144.
• [73] 刘永学，戴玉良，黄国鹰.熔敷防磨技术在循环流化床锅炉上的应用[J].中国设备工程，2016(1):64-65.LIU Yongxue,DAI Yuliang,HUANG Guoying.Application of deposition anti-wear technology in circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].China Plant Engineering,2016(1):64-65.
• [74] 李义章，金跃鹏.等离子熔滴熔敷技术在240 t/h循环流化床锅炉上的应用[J].纯碱工业，2017(5):44-45.LI Yizhang,JIN Yuepeng.Application of plasma droplet deposition technology on 240 t/h circulating fluidized bed boiler[J].Soda Industry,2017(5):44-45.
• [75] 潘应君，许伯藩，张细菊.La2O3对激光熔覆TiC/Ni基复合涂层的影响[J].稀土，2003,24(4):49-52.PAN Yingjun,XU Bofan,ZHANG Xiju.Effects of La2O3 on TiC/Ni metal-ceramic coatings by laser cladding[J].Chinese Rare Earths,2003,24(4):49-52.
• [76] 钟成圆.高耐磨损复合锅炉管的制备及其特性研究[D].保定：华北电力大学，2013.
• [77] 韩春峰.循环流化床锅炉炉膛水冷壁磨损与防磨关键技术[J].化工设计通讯，2019,45(9):68,87.HAN Chunfeng.Key technology of wear and wear of water wall in Circulating Fluidized Bed boiler[J].Chemical Engineering Design Communications,2019,45(9):68,87.
• [78] 高建新，赵勇.燕山石化410 t/h循环流化床锅炉磨损分析与防磨措施应用[J].中外能源，2021,26(3):72-79.GAO Jianxin,ZHAO Yong.Wear analysis of 410 t/h circulating fluidized bed boiler in Yanshan and the application of anti-wear measures[J].Sino-Global Energy,2021,26(3):72-79.
• [79] 杨茂鑫，何屏，罗显雨.国产300 MW循环流化床锅炉防磨技术[J].科学技术与工程，2011,11(35):8898-8901.YANG Maoxin,HE Ping,LUO Xianyu.The anti-abrasion measure of the China-made 300 MW CFB boiler[J].Science Technology and Engineering,2011,11(35):8898-8901.
• [80] 中国石油网消息.独山子石化CFB锅炉长周期运行刷新纪录[EB/OL].[2022-01-14].https://www.cnpc.com.cn/cnpc/lyxgdt/202202/eb767cade29042aa81fbe7ab7b2d7b5a.shtml.