化学链燃烧钙基载氧体研究进展Recent advances of calcium-based oxygen carriers for the chemical looping combustion process
狄子琛,巩盼,杨凤玲,宋慧平,程芳琴
DI Zichen,GONG Pan,YANG Fengling,SONG Huiping,CHENG Fangqin
摘要(Abstract):
化石能源燃烧产生大量CO_2,碳捕集、利用与封存技术是目前唯一能实现化石能源大规模低碳化利用的减排技术。化学链燃烧是一种新的解耦燃烧技术,可在燃烧过程中实现原位碳捕集。载氧体是该过程高效稳定运行的关键。钙基载氧体因其特有的高载氧量、低成本、易获得且对环境友好等优势被认为具有应用潜力。总结了化学链燃烧技术及6类常见载氧体的原理及发展,重点介绍了钙基载氧体存在的瓶颈问题——热力学和动力学适宜温区、分压匹配难,总结了国内外通过控制反应条件、添加剂等手段调控反应过程,强化其反应性和再生性的相关研究,并解析了惰性载体、金属氧化物等添加剂对钙基载氧体性能的强化效应和影响机制。研究表明,惰性载体可有效改善载氧体分散特性,从而提升反应活性,有助于提高机械强度。与惰性载体相比,添加金属氧化物可能更有效。传统的功能强化方法可一定程度改善载氧体性能,但难以从根本上突破其再生性差的瓶颈。未来研究可聚焦2方面:基于人工智能在材料科学中的应用,定向筛选与优化廉价钙基天然矿石/工业固废等材料作为载氧体;重构载氧体的形貌构造和晶体结构,调控氧原子、硫原子的迁移转化行为,降低氧传递对硫原子的携带效应,实现再生性能强化。
Fossil fuel combustion emits large amounts of CO_2,and carbon capture, utilization and storage(CCUS) is currently the only emission reduction technology that can realize large-scale low-carbon utilization of fossil energy. Chemical looping combustion(CLC) is a recently developed decoupled combustion technology, which can realize in situ carbon capture during combustion. Oxygen carrier is one of key component for developing and optimizing of the CLC technology. Calcium-based oxygen carriers have potential applications due to their unique characteristics of high oxygen loading capacity, low cost, wide availability and environment benign. The principles and development of chemical looping combustion technology, as well as six common types of oxygen carriers, were summarized. The bottleneck problem of calcium-based oxygen carriers, which are difficult to match the appropriate thermodynamic and kinetic temperature and partial pressure zones, were emphatically introduced. In this paper, the relevant researches on the regulation of reaction process by controlling reaction conditions and additives at home and abroad were summarized, and the strengthening effect and influence mechanism of inert carriers, metal oxides and other additives on the performance of calcium based oxygen carriers were analyzed. It has been demonstrated that inert carriers can be effective in improving the dispersion characteristics of the oxygen carriers, thereby increasing reactivity, and contributing to mechanical strength. In comparison to inert carriers, the addition of metal oxides is likely to be more effective. However, in terms of current research progress, traditional functional strengthening methods can improve the performance of oxygen carriers to a degree, but it is difficult to fundamentally breaking the bottleneck of poor regenerative properties. Future research can focus on two aspects to address this issue: utilizing artificial intelligence in materials science, targeted screening and optimization of inexpensive calcium-based natural ores/industrial solid waste materials as oxygen carriers, reconstructing the morphological structure and crystal structure of oxygen carriers to regulate the migration and transformation behavior of oxygen and sulphur atoms, so as to reduce the carrying effect of oxygen transfer on sulfur atoms and achieve regeneration performance enhancement.
关键词(KeyWords):
碳捕集;化学链燃烧;钙基载氧体;廉价载氧体;晶体结构调控
CO_2 capture;chemical looping combustion;calcium-based oxygen carrier;low-cost oxygen carrier;crystal structure modulation
基金项目(Foundation): 山西省基础研究计划(自由探索类)资助项目(202103021223027);; 山西省省筹资金资助回国留学人员科研资助项目(2022-018)
作者(Author):
狄子琛,巩盼,杨凤玲,宋慧平,程芳琴
DI Zichen,GONG Pan,YANG Fengling,SONG Huiping,CHENG Fangqin
DOI: 10.13226/j.issn.1006-6772.21102901
参考文献(References):
- [1] BOZZANO G,MANENTI F.Efficient methanol synthesis:Perspectives,technologies and optimization strategies[J].Progress in Energy and Combustion Science,2016,56:71-105.
- [2] SONG C,LIU Q,DENG S,et al.Cryogenic-based CO2 capture technologies:State-of-the-art developments and current challenges[J].Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2019,101:265-278.
- [3] OSMAN A I,HEFNY M,MAKSOUD M,et al.Recent advances in carbon capture storage and utilisation technologies:A review[J].Environmental Chemistry Letters,2021,19(1):797-849.
- [4] OMOREGBE O,MUSTAPHA A N,STEINBERGER-WILCKENS R,et al.Carbon capture technologies for climate change mitigation:A bibliometric analysis of the scientific discourse during 1998-2018[J].Energy Reports,2020,6:1200-1212.
- [5] THURSFIELD A,MURUGAN A,FRANCA R,et al.Chemical looping and oxygen permeable ceramic membranes for hydrogen production:A review[J].Energy & Environmental Science,2012,5:7421-7459.
- [6] ANIRBAN N,CHANCHAL L,SAI G,et al.Present status and overview of chemical looping combustion technology[J].Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,2016,59:597-619.
- [7] ADANEZ J,ABAD A,GARCIA-LABIANO F,et al.Progress in chemical-looping combustion and reforming technologies[J].Progress in Energy & Combustion Science,2012,38(2):215-282.
- [8] 胡东海,黄戒介,李春玉,等.固体化学链燃烧技术及污染物释放研究进展[J].洁净煤技术,2020,26(4):1-10.HU Donghai,HUANG Jiejie,LI Chunyu,et al.Research progress on chemical-looping combustion and pollutant release for solid fuels[J].Clean Coal Technology,2020,26(4):1-10.
- [9] 白歆慰,刘金昌,白磊.煤化学链燃烧载氧体研究进展[J].洁净煤技术,2021,27(2):31-44.BAI Xinwei,LIU Jinchang,BAI Lei.Recent advances in oxygen carriers for chemical looping combustion of coal[J].Clean Coal Technology,2021,27(2):31-44.
- [10] RICHTER H J,KNOCHE K F.Reversibility of combustion proc-esses[J].ACS Symposium Series,1983,235:71-86.
- [11] ISHIDA M,JIN H.A new advanced power-generation system using chemical-looping combustion[J].Energy,1994,19(4):415-422.
- [12] LYNGFELT A,THUNMAN H.Construction and 100 h of operational experience of a 10 kW chemical-looping combustor[J].Carbon Dioxide Capture for Storage in Deep Geologic Formations[J].2005,1:625-645.
- [13] ADáNEZ J,GARCá-LABIANO F,GAYáN P,et al.Effect of gas impurities on the behavior of Ni-based oxygen carriers on chemical-looping combustion[J].Energy Procedia,2009,1(1):11-18.
- [14] ABDULALLY I,BEAL C,ANDRUS H,et al.Alstom′s chemi-cal looping prototypes,program update[C]//37th International Technical Conference on Clean Coal & Fuel Systems.Clearwater:[s.n.],2012.
- [15] JUAN A,ALBERTO A,FRANCISCO G,et al.Progress inchemical-looping-combustion and reforming technologies[J].Progress in Energy and Combustion Science,2012,38(2):215-282.
- [16] 李振山,成茂,陈虎,等.3 MWth化学链燃烧装置设计方法[J].新能源进展,2018,6(3):169-174.LI Zhenshan,CHENG Mao,CHEN Hu,et al.Design method of 3 MWth chemical looping combustion system[J].Advances in New and Renewable Energy,2018,6(3):169-174.
- [17] JUAN A,ALBERTO A.Chemical-looping-combustion:Status and research needs[J].Proceedings of the Combustion In-stitute,2019,37(4):4303-4317.
- [18] MATTISSON T,JOHANSSON M,LYNGFELT A.The use of NiO as an oxygen carrier in chemical-looping combustion[J].Fuel,2006,85(5/6):736-747.
- [19] LEION H,LYNGFELT A,MATTISSON T.Solid fuels in chemical-looping combustion using a NiO-based oxygen carrier[J].Chemical Engineering Research & Design,2009,87(11):1543-1550.
- [20] 牛欣,沈来宏,蒋守席,等.基于赤铁矿载氧体的污泥化学链燃烧研究[J].工程热物理学报,2015,36(8):1830-1834.NIU Xin,SHEN Laihong,JIANG Shouxi,et al.Chemical looping combustion of sewage sludge based on hematite[J].Journal of Engineering Thermophysics,2015,36(8):1830-1834.
- [21] WANG B W,WANG W S,ZHAO H B,et al.Investigation of chemical looping combustion of coal with Fe2O3 oxygen carrier[J].Fuel,2011,90(7):2359-2366.
- [22] MOLDENHAUER P,RYDEN M,LYNGFELT A.Testing of mi-nerals and industrial by-products as oxygen carriers for chemical-looping combustion in a circulating fluidized-bed 300 W laboratory reactor[J].Fuel,2012,93:351-363.
- [23] CORBELLA B M,DIEGO L D,GARCIA F,et al.The performance in a fixed bed reactor of copper-based oxides on titania as oxygen carriers for chemical looping combustion of methane[J].Energy & Fuels,2005,19(2):433-441.
- [24] GAYáN P,FORERO C R,DIEGO L,et al.Effect of gas composition in chemical-looping combustion with copper-based oxygen carriers:Fate of light hydrocarbons[J].International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,2010,4(1):13-22.
- [25] SHULMAN A,CLEVERSTAM E,MATTISSON T,et al.Chemical-Looping with oxygen uncoupling using Mn/Mg-based oxygen carriers-oxygen release and reactivity with methane[J].Fuel,2011,90(3):941-950.
- [26] SIRIWARDANE R,TIAN H,RICHARDS G,et al.Chemical-looping-combustion of coal with metal oxide oxygen carriers[J].Energy & Fuels,2009,23(4):3885-3892.
- [27] 郑瑛,王保文,宋侃,等.化学链燃烧技术中新型载氧体CaSO4的特性研究[J].工程热物理学报,2006,27(3):531-533.ZHENG Ying,WANG Baowen,SONG Kan,et al.The performance research on new oxygen carrier CaSO4 used in chemical-looping combustion[J].Journal of Engineering Thermophysics,2006,27(3):531-533.
- [28] ZHENG M,SHEN L,XIAO J.Reduction of CaSO4 oxygen car-rier with coal in chemical-looping combustion:Effects of temperature and gasification intermediate[J].International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,2010,4(5):716-728.
- [29] TIAN H,GUO Q,JING C.Investigation into decomposition behavior of CaSO4 in chemical-looping combustion[J].Energy & Fuels,2008,22(6):3915-3921.
- [30] TIAN H,GUO Q.Investigation into the behavior of reductive decomposition of calcium sulfate by carbon monoxide in chemical-looping combustion[J].Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research,2009,48(12):5624-5632.
- [31] SONG Q,XIAO R,DENG Z,et al.Multicycle study on chemical-looping combustion of simulated coal gas with a CaSO4 oxygen carrier in a fluidized bed reactor[J].Energy & Fuels,2008,22(6):3661-3672.
- [32] VOS Y D,JACOBS M,VOORT P V D,et al.Development of stable oxygen carrier materials for chemical looping processes:A review[J].Catalysts,2020,10(8):926.
- [33] GUO Q,ZHANG J,TIAN H.Recent advances in CaSO4 oxygen carrier for chemical-looping combustion(CLC) process[J].Chemical Engineering Communications,2012,199(11):1463-1491.
- [34] 丁宁,郑瑛,罗聪,等.钙基复合载氧体反应性能的研究[J].动力工程学报,2010,30(9):689-694,698.DING Ning,ZHENG Ying,LUO Cong,et al.Experimental study on reactivity of calcium-based compound oxygen carriers[J].Journal of Chinese Society of Power Engineering,2010,30(9):689-694,698.
- [35] 刘海涛,高海潮,高志芳.化学链燃烧工艺中载氧体的研究进展[J].洁净煤技术,2018,24(5):12-19.LIU Haitao,GAO Haichao,GAO Zhifang.Progress on oxygen carrier in chemical-looping combustion[J].Clean Coal Technology,2018,24(5):12-19.
- [36] 周树理.非混合燃烧中CaSO4载氧体的研究[D].北京:中国科学院研究生院(工程热物理研究所),2007.
- [37] LIU S,LEE D,LIU M,et al.Selection and application of binders for CaSO4 oxygen carrier in chemical-looping combustion[J].Energy & Fuels,2010,24:6675-6681.
- [38] 贾伟华.煤化学链燃烧钙基复合载氧体的制备及性能研究[D].青岛:青岛科技大学,2014.
- [39] 杨勤勤.钙铜、铁铜双组分复合载氧体的化学链燃烧性能研究[D].青岛:青岛科技大学,2016.
- [40] WANG Baoyi,MOLDENHAUER P,LEION H.Using Mn-Si oxygen carriers supported with CaO or Al2O3 for converting methane and syngas in chemical-looping with oxygen uncoupling (CLOU)[J].Fuel Processing Technology,2020,201(2):106315.
- [41] QASIM M,AYOUB M,AQSHA A,et al.Preparation of metal oxide-based oxygen carriers supported with CeO2 and gamma-Al2O3 for chemical looping combustion[J].Chemical Engineering & Technology,2021,44(4):782-787.
- [42] AMINI A,OHNO K I,MA Eda T,et al.A kinetic comparison between microwave heating and conventional heating of FeS-CaO mixture during hydrogen-reduction[J].Chemical Enginee-ring Journal,2019,374:648-657.
- [43] YANG Jie,MA Liping,YANG Jing,et al.Thermodynamic and kinetic analysis of CuO-CaSO4 oxygen carrier in chemical looping gasification[J].Energy,2019,188:116109.
- [44] WANG B,LI H,WANG W,et al.Chemical looping combustion of lignite with the CaSO4-CoO mixed oxygen carrier[J].Journal of the Energy Institute,2020,93(3):1229-1241.
- [45] MIHARA N,KUCHAR D,KOJIMA Y,et al.Reductive decomposition of waste gypsum with SiO2,Al2O3,and Fe2O3 additives[J].Journal of Material Cycles & Waste Management,2007,9(1):21-26.
- [46] 魏泽华,刘道诚,荆洁颖,等.化学链燃烧中铁基载氧体研究进展[J].洁净煤技术,2019,25(3):19-27.WEI Zehua,LIU Daocheng,JING Jieying,et al.Research progress on Fe-based oxygen carrier in chemical looping combustion[J].Clean Coal Technology,2019,25(3):19-27.
- [47] ZHANG Shuai,XIAO Rui,LIU Jian,et al.Performance of Fe2O3/CaSO4 composite oxygen carrier on inhibition of sulfur release in calcium-based chemical looping combustion[J].International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,2013,17:1-12.
- [48] ZHANG S,XIAO R,LIU J,et al.Performance of Fe2O3/CaSO4 composite oxygen carrier on inhibition of sulfur release in calcium-based chemical looping combustion[J].International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,2013,17:1-12.
- [49] ZHENG Min,SHEN Laihong.In situ gasification chemical looping combustion of coal using the mixed oxygen carrier of natural anhydrite ore and calcined limestone[J].International Journal of Chemical Reactor Engineering,2016,14(2):637-652.
- [50] DING N,ZHANG C,LUO C,et al.Effect of hematite addition to CaSO4 oxygen carrier in chemical looping combustion of coal char[J].RSC Advances,2015,5(69):56362-56376.
- [51] SUNPHORKA S,KANOKWANNAKORN P,KUCHONTHARA P.Chemical looping combustion of methane or coal by Fe2O3/CaSO4 mixed oxygen carrier[J].Arabian Journal for Science & Engineering,2019,44:5501-5512.
- [52] ZHANG S,XIAO R,LIU J,et al.Performance of Fe2O3/CaSO4composite oxygen carrier on inhibition of sulfur release in calcium-based chemical looping combustion[J].International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,2013,17:1-12.
- [53] WANG B,LI J,DING N,et al.Chemical looping combustion of a typical lignite with a CaSO4-CuO mixed oxygen carrier[J].Energy & Fuels,2017,31(12):13942-13954.
- [54] MIHARA N,KUCHAR D ,KOJIMA Y,et al.Reductive decomposition of waste gypsum with SiO2,Al2O3 and Fe2O3 additives[J].Journal of Material Cycles & Waste Management,2007,9(1):21-26.
- [55] 郑敏,沈来宏.CaSO4氧载体与CO反应中Boudouard反应的热力学分析及其抑制研究[J].化工进展,2013,32(12):2846-2851.ZHENG Min,SHEN Laihong.Thermodynamic analysis and suppress research on the boudouard reaction in the reaction of CaSO4 oxygen carrier with CO[J].Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress,2013,32(12):2846-2851.
- [56] DI Zichen ,YANG Fengling ,CAO Yan ,et al.The transformati-on pathways on the catalytic and stability-promoted CaSO4 reduction in CLC process using Fe2O3 supported[J].Fuel,2019,253:327-338.
- [57] MICHAEL M,PINKERTON J,WANG X,et al.Use of natural ores as oxygen carriers in chemical looping combustion:A review[J].International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,2017,65:1-14.
- [58] 沈来宏,肖军,蒋守席,等.基于水泥修饰的赤铁矿载氧体污泥化学链燃烧特性研究[J].燃料化学学报,2015,43(11):1402-1408.SHEN Laihong,XIAO Jun,JIANG Shouxi,et al.Chemical looping combustion of sewage sludge with oxygen carrier of cement-modified hematite[J].Journal of Fuel Chemistry and Technology,2015,43(11):1402-1408.
- [59] WANG X,GONG Y,WANG X,et al.Experimental and kinetics investigations of separated-gasification chemical looping combustion of char with an iron ore as the oxygen carrier[J].Fuel Processing Technology,2020,210:106554.
- [60] SUN Z,LU D Y,SYMONDS R T,et al.Chemical looping reforming of CH4 in the presence of CO2 using ilmenite ore and NiO-modified ilmenite ore oxygen carriers[J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2019,401:123481.
- [61] MAYER K,PIESENBERGER S,PENTHOR S,et al.Chemical looping combustion using two different perovskite based oxygen carriers:A pilot study[J].Energy Technology (Weinheim,Germany),2018,6(12):2333-2343.
- [62] HAMM Ac He S,MEANS N,BURGESS W,et al.Investigation of low-cost oxygen carriers for chemical looping combustion at high temperature[J].Fuel,2020,273:117746.
- [63] CHEN L,ZHANG Y,LIU F,et al.Development of a cost-effective oxygen carrier from red mud for coal-fueled chemical-looping combustion[J].Energy & Fuels,2015,29(1):305-313.
- [64] DENG Guixian ,LI Kongzhai ,GU Zhenhua ,et al.Synergy ef-fects of combined red muds as oxygen carriers for chemical looping combustion of methane[J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2018,341:588-600.
- [65] SONIA H,NICHOLAS M,WARD B,et al.Investigation of low-cost oxygen carriers for chemical looping combustion at high temperature[J].Fuel,2020,273:117746.
- [66] FREDRIK H,HENRIK L,CARL J L,et al.Steel converter slag as an oxygen carrier for chemical-looping gasification[J].Fuel Processing Technology,2020,210:106576.
- [67] MOLDENHAUER P,LINDERHOLM C,RYDéN M ,et al.Avoiding CO2 capture effort and cost for negative CO2 emissions using industrial waste in chemical-looping combustion/gasification of biomass[J].Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change,2020,25(1):1-24.
- [68] ABAD A,OBRAS-LOSCERTALES M,GARCíA-LABIANO F,et al.In situ gasification chemical-looping combustion of coal using limestone as oxygen carrier precursor and sulphur sorbent[J].Chemical Engineering Journal,2016,310(1):226-239.
- [69] SONG Q,RUI X,DENG Z,et al.Reactivity of a CaSO4-oxygen carrier in chemical-looping combustion of methane in a fixed bed reactor[J].Korean Journal of Chemical Engineering,2009,26(2):592-602.
- [70] RUI X,SONG Q.Characterization and kinetics of reduction of CaSO4 with carbon monoxide for chemical-looping combustion[J].Combustion & Flame,2011,158(12):2524-2539.
- [71] ZHANG S,XIAO R,LIU J,et al.Performance of Fe2O3/CaSO4 composite oxygen carrier on inhibition of sulfur release in calcium-based chemical looping combustion[J].International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control,2013,17:1-12.
- 碳捕集
- 化学链燃烧
- 钙基载氧体
- 廉价载氧体
- 晶体结构调控
CO_2 capture - chemical looping combustion
- calcium-based oxygen carrier
- low-cost oxygen carrier
- crystal structure modulation