HUANG Hui;LIU Jun;CUI Hongbin;LI Yanghai;LIU Li;HE Jun;XU Wanbing;WANG Nan;ZHOU Miao;XU Tao;XU Yan;

• 1:State Grid Hubei Electric Power Research Institute
• 2:Hubei Fangyuan Dongli Electric Power Science & Research Limited Company
• 3:School of Energy Science and Engineering
• 4:Harbin Institute of Technology

Abstract：

The carbon emission of the power industry accounts for more than 40% of the total carbon emission in China. Accelerating the improvement of the accurate measurement and uncertainty assessment method of carbon emission of thermal power plants plays an important role in the fine supervision of carbon emission of the power industry. Considering that the measuring performance and accuracy of the concentration, flow and other measuring instruments installed on the power plant site may change after long-term operation, using the factory accuracy of the meters to calculate the uncertainty cannot truly reflect the confidence level of the measurement. In this paper, an improved practical method for uncertainty assessment based on the periodic calibration results of the instruments was proposed. The method was used to evaluate the uncertainty of the online monitoring results of carbon emissions for a 660 MW power plant in Hubei Province, the contribution of uncertainty was analyzed, and optimization suggestions were proposed. The results show that the extended relative uncertainty of the carbon measurement results obtained by the direct measurement method is 8.282%(including factor k=2, confidence level 95%). With the exception of pressure, all other terms are dominated by class B uncertainty. Whether to consider the sensitivity coefficient and the choice of the evaluation method of Class B uncertainty will have a significant impact on the results. The main sources of carbon emission uncertainty are carbon dioxide concentration and flue gas flow measurement. The use of higher precision gas composition and flow measurement instruments, regular maintenance and calibration of measuring instruments, and optimization of measuring point layout in the flue can help reduce the uncertainty.

Key Words： carbon dioxide emission;carbon accounting;carbon monitoring;direct measurement;uncertainty;coal-fired power plant

Abstract:

Keywords:

Foundation: 国网湖北省电力有限公司成本专项资助项目(B11532232993)

Authors: HUANG Hui;LIU Jun;CUI Hongbin;LI Yanghai;LIU Li;HE Jun;XU Wanbing;WANG Nan;ZHOU Miao;XU Tao;XU Yan;

DOI: 10.13226/j.issn.1006-6772.LC24073001

References：

• [1] 吴昊，任鑫，朱俊杰.发电行业二氧化碳排放监测技术现状与综述[J].热力发电，2023,52(7):1-13.WU Hao,REN Xin,ZHU Junjie.Current situation and review of carbon dioxide emission monitoring technology in power generation industry[J].Thermal Power Generation,2023,52(7):1-13.
• [2] 鲁非，张露，卢仰泽，等.基于电网全过程链的变压器碳排放测算与评价研究框架及应用展望[J].湖北电力，2022,46(4):113-119.LU Fei,ZHANG Lu,LU Yangze,et al.Transformer carbon emission measurement,evaluation research framework and application prospect based on whole process chain of power grid[J].Hubei Electric Power,2022,46(4):113-119.
• [3] 郭振，王小龙，任健，等.二氧化碳排放连续在线监测过程的模拟与不确定度评定[J].计量学报，2022,43(1):120-126.GUO Zhen,WANG Xiaolong,REN Jian,et al.Simulation and uncertainty evaluation of continuous on-line monitoring process of carbon dioxide emission[J].Acta Metrologica Sinica,2022,43(1):120-126.
• [4] 刘科，杨兴森，王太，等.基于实时监测的燃煤机组碳排放特性研究[J].热力发电，2022,51(10):47-53.LIU Ke,YANG Xingsen,WANG Tai,et al.Research on carbon emission characteristics of coal-fired units based on real-time monitoring[J].Thermal Power Generation,2022,51(10):47-53.
• [5] 卢伟业，陈小玄，陆继东，等.双碳背景下火电企业碳计量分析与建议[J].洁净煤技术，2023,29(1):194-203.LU Weiye,CHEN Xiaoxuan,LU Jidong,et al.Analysis and suggestion on carbon accounting of thermal power enterprises under the background of carbon peak and carbon neutrality[J].Clean Coal Technology,2023,29(1):194-203.
• [6] 王萍萍，赵永椿，张军营，等.双碳目标下燃煤电厂碳计量方法研究进展[J].洁净煤技术，2022,28(10):170-183.WANG Pingping,ZHAO Yongchun,ZHANG Junying,et al.Research progress on carbon measurement methods of coal-fired power plants under the background of carbon neutrality[J].Clean Coal Technology,2022,28(10):170-183.
• [7] 刘广一，王继业，汤亚宸，等.电网碳排放因子研究方向与应用需求的演变进程[J].电网技术，2024,48(1):12-28.LIU Guangyi,WANG Jiye,TANG Yachen,et al.Evolution process of research directions and application requirements of electricity carbon emission factors[J].Power System Technology,2024,48(1):12-28.
• [8] 姚顺春，刘泽明，卢志民，等.软测量技术赋能燃煤电厂碳排放计量的研究进展[J/OL].洁净煤技术，1-18[2024-08-12].http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.3676.TD.20240511.1521.002.html.YAO Shunchun,LIU Zeming,LU Zhimin,et al.Research progress of soft measurement technology optimizing carbon emission measurement of coal-fired power plants [J/OL].Clean Coal Technology,1-18[2024-08-12].http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/11.3676.TD.20240511.1521.002.html.
• [9] QUICK J C.Carbon dioxide emission tallies for 210U.S.coal-fired power plants:A comparison of two accounting methods[J].Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association,2014,64(1):73-79.
• [10] 陈公达，邹祥波，卢锐，等.中外火电企业碳排放统计方法与质量控制现状分析[J].热力发电，2022,51(10):54-60.CHEN Gongda,ZOU Xiangbo,LU Rui,et al.Domestic and international statistical methods and quality control status for carbon emission from fossil-fired power plants[J].Thermal Power Generation,2022,51(10):54-60.
• [11] 程兰芬，周保荣，张东辉，等.中国低碳电力的发展方向与实施路径[J].湖北电力，2018,42(6):48-54.CHENG Lanfen,ZHOU Baorong,ZHANG Donghui,et al.The development direction and implementation path of low caron power system in China[J].Hubei Electric Power,2018,42(6):48-54.
• [12] 姚顺春，支嘉琦，付金杯，等.火电企业碳排放在线监测技术研究进展[J].华南理工大学学报(自然科学版),2023,51(6):97-108.YAO Shunchun,ZHI Jiaqi,FU Jinbei,et al.Research progress of online carbon emission monitoring technology for thermal power enterprises[J].Journal of South China University of Technology (Natural Science Edition),2023,51(6):97-108.
• [13] 杨美昭.企业温室气体排放量监测计量方法研究[D].保定：河北大学，2021.
• [14] 王静，郑张，张铭.碳排放连续检测气体分析仪测量结果的不确定度研究[J].山东化工，2019,48(21):98-99.WANG Jing,ZHENG Zhang,ZHANG Ming.Study on uncertainty of measurement results of carbon emission continuous detection gas analyzer[J].Shandong Chemical Industry,2019,48(21):98-99.
• [15] 王霂晗.火电厂碳排放监测体系与核算方法的研究[D].南京：南京信息工程大学，2020.
• [16] MAJANNE Y,KORPELA T,UOTILA T.EU emission trading related CO2 monitoring in power plants[J].IFAC Proceedings Volumes,2014,47(3):1361-1366.
• [17] 饶雨舟，李越胜，姚顺春，等.碳排放在线检测技术的研究进展[J].广东电力，2015,28(8):1-8.RAO Yuzhou,LI Yuesheng,YAO Shunchun,et al.Research development of online detection technology for carbon emission[J].Guangdong Electric Power,2015,28(8):1-8.
• [18] SUN Shuanzhu ,ZHOU Chunlei ,WANG Ming ,et al.The exten-sion of continuous carbon emission monitoring system in China′s thermal power plants under the carbon market[J].IOP Conference Series Earth and Environmental Science,2020,467:012165.
• [19] 张铭，葛志伟，郑张，等.碳排放在线检测中CO2示值误差测得值的不确定度分析[J].计量与测试技术，2019,46(8):110-111,118.ZHANG Ming,GE Zhiwei,ZHENG Zhang,et al.Uncertainty analysis of the measurement result of CO2 indication error in on-line detection of carbon emissions[J].Metrology & Measurement Technique,2019,46(8):110-111,118.
• [20] 徐凯，钟平，宋金时，等.垃圾焚烧电站入炉垃圾低位热值及不确定度研究[J].洁净煤技术，2022,28(2) :169-174.XU Kai,ZHONG Ping,SONG Jinshi,et al.Low level calorific value and uncertainty of waste in MSW incineration power plant[J].Clean Coal Technology,2022,28( 2) :169-174.